Your state. Your news. Your voice.
Indy Voices Logo
Indy Voices Logo
Indy Voices Logo
Indy Voices Logo
Indy Voices Logo
Indy Voices Logo
Indy Voices Logo

OPINION: Choosing a president by popular vote would disenfranchise Nevadans

The Electoral College system isn’t perfect. But Gov.-elect Ford’s push to join the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is even more wrongheaded.
SHARE
(Photo illustration by Rodolfo Martinez/The Nevada Independent)

Apparently, Gov.-elect Aaron Ford (D) wants to let voters in 49 other states determine how Nevada's Electoral College votes are cast in future presidential elections. 

While describing the "racist underpinnings" of the Electoral College, Ford said he would like to see America "get rid of" it and replace the cumbersome process we currently use to elect presidents. 

With the Electoral College, each state is assigned a number of electors based on its number of members of Congress. Those electors then cast their ballots according to the election results in their state, and the presidential candidate who receives 270 (or more) from across the nation is elected to the highest executive office in the land. 

To be fair, that is a decidedly less straightforward approach than, say, adding up the total national votes cast by citizens for each candidate and declaring whoever has more to be the winner. 

However, since abolishing such a process would require amending the U.S. Constitution — which isn't likely to happen anytime soon — Ford is apparently content with merely pushing Nevada into the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. 

The idea behind the compact is simple enough: Participating states pledge their Electoral College votes to whichever candidate wins the popular vote nationwide. If enough states join, it will eliminate the possibility of one candidate winning the popular vote but still losing the Electoral College vote — as was the case in 2016. 

The problem with the compact, however, is that it is explicitly designed to ensure participating states disregard the preferences of their own voters in exchange for those of a national majority. 

Ignoring the will of a state's voters is hardly a democratic fix to our current system.

To be sure, the current process can also occasionally produce undemocratic results. (Such as the 2016 election.) However, if we would like to protect the interests, concerns and preferences of Nevadans when it comes to presidential politics, surrendering our authority over how our Electoral College votes are cast is going to have some massive unintended consequences. 

It would also be an affront to the federalist principles that help protect political minorities, small states and underrepresented regions of this nation from populist majorities elsewhere. 

Indeed, much of our American form of government — including the Electoral College — was designed to protect against mob rule by ensuring all states, regardless of population, are meaningfully represented on the federal level. In the same way the U.S. Senate is the undemocratic counterweight to the House of Representatives, the Electoral College was devised as a check against executive authority being accumulated from a regional majority that didn't represent the geographic or cultural diversity of the nation as a whole.  

Certainly, in the late 1700s, that geographic and cultural "diversity" included Southerners' intent on perpetuating the grotesque practice of slavery. However, in our modern era it includes a plethora of regional concerns far less insulting to common decency.

For example, the concerns of Nevadans in the sprawling, arid land of the American West are inherently going to differ from those of New Yorkers or Bay Staters living in densely populated coastal cities out East. And yet, despite there being far more people in New York and Massachusetts than in Nevada, connecting with voters in the Silver State has become an indispensable part of any serious presidential campaign. 

And the reason why is because our six Electoral College votes are up for grabs each year.  

Indeed, competitive and swingy states — such as Nevada — are only considered important battlegrounds because presidential candidates have to win numerous state elections (to win enough Electoral College votes) rather than a single national majority. If not for our ability to determine who gets our precious six votes, there would be little (if any) incentive for candidates to visit our corner of the map, let alone cater to whatever unique concerns are prevalent among our electorate. 

After all, whatever block of voters a candidate might add to their total national vote tally from Nevada would likely be statistically insignificant. Nevada had roughly 1.48 million voters show up in the last presidential election, which is a drop in the bucket compared to the more than 150 million who showed up throughout the rest of the nation. With the exception of the incredibly close election in 2000, every popular vote total this century has had a margin of victory that was significantly larger than the total number of votes cast in the Silver State — meaning even if Nevadans went to the polls in record numbers, they wouldn't be numerous enough to alter the outcome of any normal presidential election. 

That math does not bode well for continued relevance in national politics.

Just as worrisome is that, in certain circumstances, the compact would also require the state to award our Electoral College votes to a candidate whom Nevadans might overwhelmingly reject. 

In the 2000 presidential election, for example, Al Gore narrowly won the popular vote but famously lost the Electoral College after a kerfuffle of recounts and court cases in Florida. Had Nevada belonged to a national popular vote compact at the time, the outcome of that election would have been different. However, it also would have meant that Nevada's electoral votes would have gone to Gore, despite more Nevadans having cast their ballot for George W. Bush. 

Allocating the state's electoral votes to any candidate other than the one Nevadans select is an insult to the voters who expect their ballots to actually mean something. And yet, that's precisely what the compact will require whenever our citizens' collective preferences don't align with a majority of voters elsewhere. 

Even for those who feel the Electoral College has outlived its usefulness as a bulwark against mob rule or "tyranny of the majority," that should feel like a decidedly anti-democratic alternative to our admittedly imperfect status quo. 

Michael Schaus is a communications and branding expert based in Las Vegas and founder of Schaus Creative LLC, an agency dedicated to helping organizations, businesses and activists tell their story and motivate change. He has more than a decade of experience in public affairs commentary, having worked as a news director, columnist, political humorist and most recently as the director of communications for a public policy think tank. Follow him on Twitter @schausmichael or on Substack @creativediscourse.

Support Independent
Journalism in Nevada

The Nevada Independent is free to read, but not free to produce. A gift of any amount keeps our reporting open to every Nevadan and funds our coverage, powered by readers like you.

(Yes, you. Hi.)

Secure donation

SHARE