This vacant piece of land at Russell Road and Interstate 15 is the site of the new Raiders Stadium. Photo by Jeff Scheid/The Nevada Independent.

The cheering had barely subsided at the Clark County Government Center, but Don Murphy wasn’t among those joining in the political tailgate party that takes place whenever the proposed $1.9 billion domed football stadium project is on the commission agenda.

The commission voted Sept. 6 to continue to move forward with the stadium that will serve as a new home for the Las Vegas Raiders in 2020 despite an obvious lack of sufficient parking and an analysis that reads like a sitcom script.  This time even Commissioner Chris Giunchigliani, the project’s only consistent critic on the county board, joined the elected cheer squad led from the first day by gubernatorial aspirant and Chairman Steve Sisolak.

Most locals didn’t need further proof, but the vote was more evidence that the stadium project — despite the challenges of the selected site — is pressing forward at full throttle. Its use of $750 million in public financing via room-tax revenues makes it the most generous gift to an NFL franchise on record. And, I’ll speculate, the giving has only begun despite the provisions codified in the enabling funding legislation, Senate Bill 1.

Murphy, meanwhile, isn’t waving pennants and pompoms. He remains entrenched on the sidelines. Although he might not find many in the business community willing to speak up with him these days, he suspects he’s not alone. As a strategic advisor for charismatic philanthropist and real estate developer Fred Nassiri, Murphy has studied the winning stadium proposal with a critical eye and has concluded neither the financing nor the promised economic impact adds up. And its location creates almost as many problems as it solves.

Of course, he knows some will write off his skepticism as sour grapes. Nassiri in December saw his own stadium plan passed over. It was designed for his land near the Blue Diamond Road interchange south of the winning site, which enjoys superior road infrastructure, ample space for parking, and no flood channel running through it.

It also lacked the undying affection enjoyed by the winning site.

But that’s just one of the mysteries associated with the stadium obsession, which has continued to move forward despite the departure of its early promoters, real estate developer Ed Roski and casino king Sheldon Adelson. It’s hard to imagine either wily mogul missing any deal, much less this one. That is, if it’s actually a moneymaker.

Murphy has serious doubts the Raiders will be able to service their financial obligations after the team’s honeymoon ends.

“I seriously question their ability to service the debt with the facility structure and issues that they’re going to have,” Murphy says. “… I don’t think anyone is opposed to bringing the Raiders here. I just think that the autonomy that has been given without careful fiduciary oversight and due diligence has by the state should be more closely examined.”

That view sounds like a lot of armchair quarterbacking and needless fretting to the stadium’s elected and appointed promoters, who like to talk about all the public meetings that have taken place and all the professional analysis and due diligence that’s been conducted.

Perhaps it’s the thick air of inevitability that hovers over the project that has Murphy’s eyes watering. No issue seems too large to change the mind of anyone in authority. The deal is done.

Laughable lack of parking? No problem.

Millions in road and infrastructure improvements needed? Get the checkbook.

Flood channel apparently no expert saw before the site was selected? Hey, these things happen.

Questionable transparency in the Raiders’ financing of the deal? Nothing to see here. Let’s move along.

Murphy was raised in Las Vegas, where it’s always better to go with the flow of the political juice. Instead, he insists the numbers used in the financial analysis inflate the upside enough to float a halftime blimp. Once the enthusiasm subsides, the numbers are real and will be used to prop up a stadium in a community with myriad other needs.

“Economic and financial sustainability are the biggest qualifiers for an investment of this type and this magnitude,” he says. “… A  billion dollars-plus is a substantial amount of money, especially when you look at the impact one-tenth of that could have elsewhere.”

Then, in a moment of poetic understatement, he adds, “I just think there’s a discussion that’s not taking place.”

Or maybe it’s just being drowned out by all the cheerleading.

John L. Smith is a longtime Las Vegas journalist and author. Contact him at jlnevadasmith@gmail.com. On Twitter: @jlnevadasmith.

 

INDY FAST FACTS Steve Sisolak Job: Clark County commission chairman Party: Democrat In current office: 2009-present Commission chairman since 2013 Birthdate: December 26, 1953 Education: University of Wisconsin—Milwaukee (B.S.) University of Nevada, Las Vegas (M.B.A.) Other public offices held: Nevada System of Higher Education Regent (1999-2009) Total donations: $9,647,261 (1/12/11-6/7/18) Top donors: MGM Resorts International $174,359 Station Casinos/Zuffa: $90,000 Las Vegas Sands $75,000 Fidelity National $61,600 Marnell Companies LLC $55,000
INDY FAST FACTS Chris Giunchigliani Job: Clark County Commissioner Party: Democrat In current office: 2007-present Birthdate: November 27, 1954 Education: Avila College (B.A.) University of Nevada, Las Vegas (M.A.) Other public offices held: State Assemblywoman, District 9 (1991-2006) Total donations: $2,895,819 (5/08/13-6/7/18) Top donors: Giunchigliani (Chris, Jeanne, JM, Larry, Myrna, Ellen): $65,000 MGM Resorts International $43,165 Caesars Entertainment $35,000 Buck and Aurora Wong $30,000 South Point Hotel & Casino/F&M Advertising $30,000

From the Editor

The Nevada Independent is a 501c3 nonprofit. We have generous corporate donors, but we can’t survive on those alone. We need support from our readers. I know you have many commitments. But if you would support our work (or bump up your current donation), we would be forever grateful.
Best,
Jon Ralston
Donate Now
get our morning newsletter,
the daily indy
Correct Us
Ideas & Story Tips
Stars & Struggles
Take a peek into today's education world through the lens of Sunrise Acres Elementary School in Las Vegas.

INDYMATTERS

    CAFECITO CON LUZ

      EN ESPAÑOL

        INDY BLOG

          @TheNVIndy ON TWITTER