What's missing from the Kavanaugh confirmation process

By Jessica Smith-Peterson
Due process creates legitimacy. When we do not follow due process, it is difficult to claim any modicum of legitimacy. Due process is about the administration of justice and checks and balances. It extends to all government proceedings, including Supreme Court hearings. It is about striking the balance of the accuser and the accused in a just, unbiased way. It is about impartiality. It is about hearing from both corroborating and non-corroborating witnesses. It is not about making inconvenient matters go away without full and proper questioning.
This is not just true of America, but of courts and systems across the globe. When procedures become a technicality, we stop trusting the court's ability to make fair and just decisions. As everyday Americans, we need to be able to believe that the Supreme Court respects due process and is not influenced by day-to-day politics and politicians. We also need to believe that our Senate, with their crucial task of advising and consenting amidst the vast number of pages of information they receive on a nominee, follows procedure.
The allegations against Judge Kavanaugh by Dr. Christine Blasey Ford are no different. Because he is seeking the highest judicial seat in the nation, it is only fair that the allegations against Kavanaugh were and are thoroughly investigated. This is a high-stakes job interview that requires composure and honesty. It should be concerning that Senate Republicans are apparently still choosing to push forward a confirmation vote amidst an allegation that calls into question Judge Kavanaugh's character as well as his temperament on the bench.
It undermines our trust that the Senate Republicans reacted so poorly to the call for due process. Had Senator Flake not been confronted after Dr. Ford's testimony, they likely would have chosen to vote on Kavanaugh without a follow-up investigation into these allegations. Unfortunately, this flawed process is not unfamiliar to Supreme Court confirmation hearings. During the nomination of Justice Clarence Thomas, the FBI investigated the accusations of Dr. Anita Hill before a vote took place. Once that investigation ended, Dr. Hill testified, then Justice Thomas. The FBI failed to interview at least four witnesses during the investigation into Justice Thomas. Last week, Dr. Ford provided a list of at least 40 witnesses who might have assisted in the supplemental investigation, who were then actively ignored. Of the 10 people the FBI actually contacted, only nine were interviewed and neither of them included Dr. Ford nor Judge Kavanaugh.
Dr. Ford came forward. She took a polygraph. She volunteered to cooperate with the Judiciary Committee. Asked for the FBI to conduct a thorough, independent investigation. At the very least, the FBI should have spoken with all witnesses who could either confirm or deny (or reconfirm or re-deny) Judge Kavanaugh and Dr. Ford's statements made during their testimonies. As they did not, this process has become nothing more than political posturing without a fair and impartial investigation.
Last week's hearing, in many ways, was less about the truth and more about putting Dr. Ford on trial. Senators – not outside lawyers – represent us and should have been the ones asking the questions during her testimony. With just a one-week window to further "investigate," Senate Republicans are now already pushing for a vote as early as today after what still feels like an incomplete process.
This situation is less about holding someone accountable for what they did at 17 years old (even though our criminal justice system does so every single day) and more about respecting and upholding the proper process—one that applies to everyone from 17-year olds arrested and charged as juveniles or certified as an adult to Supreme Court justices during a Senate confirmation hearing. Judge Kavanaugh, as a member of our judiciary, should want to uphold this standard, even as it pertains to his own proceedings. As it stands, the lack of due process may tip in his favor — confirming him, under questionable circumstances, to the highest court in the land.
Jessica Smith-Peterson is a public defender in Las Vegas. She is a former national board member of the American Constitution Society (ACS), and current lawyer chapter leader of ACS in Nevada. Follow her on Twitter @JessicaNSmith.
Support Independent
Journalism in Nevada
The Nevada Independent is free to read, but not free to produce. A gift of any amount keeps our reporting open to every Nevadan and funds our coverage, powered by readers like you.
(Yes, you. Hi.)
Secure donation

