OPINION: Hmm, curious how Republicans don't claim fraud when MAGA wins

If there's a silver lining to a lifelong local conservative losing a primary battle to a Trumpian newcomer, it's that we don't have to endure insufferable claims of last-minute election fraud.
At least not yet.
After all, only elections that don't go the president's way are "rigged" — as is evidenced by the ridiculous claims of tomfoolery in the recent Los Angeles mayoral primary, where Republican Spencer Pratt recently lost to two Democratic opponents.
For most of us, of course, a Republican losing in L.A. is hardly surprising. But for the perpetually aggrieved wing of the Trumpian GOP, such predictable results were evidence of Stalin-style election tampering.
To be fair, California's election system has plenty of faults. For starters, it is embarrassingly inefficient compared to other states with mail-in balloting. The state also seems to prioritize voter accessibility over all other concerns — allowing for same-day registration, accepting certain ballots without postmarks and even prohibiting local jurisdictions from implementing their own voter ID requirements.
For well-intentioned individuals who expect more of a balance between accessibility, timeliness and security, there's plenty to criticize about California's election system. Of course, having a nuanced discussion about how best to balance those often conflicting policy concerns is a bit too wonky for the sort of partisan cultists who thrive off manufactured outrage.
And so, among the Trumpian wing of the GOP, the state's policies are indisputable proof of fraud and chicanery following a Republican defeat in a deep blue city, in a deep blue county in the deep blue state of California.
Indeed, MAGA's hand-wringing over the L.A. election is a glimpse into the ongoing election denialism that can be expected when results don't comport with the delusional expectations of those who reside in far-right echo chambers.
And it's not just in California where some Republicans are eager to slander the electoral process to avoid confronting their own lack of popularity among voters. Nevada, unfortunately, has its own sordid cavalcade of examples from recent elections as well.
When Joey Gilbert lost his Republican primary battle to then-Sheriff Joe Lombardo for governor in 2022, for example, he wasted no time alleging fraud despite the complete predictability of his defeat. Similarly, Republican Drew Johnson still chalks up his 2022 loss in the Clark County Commission's District F race to supposed fraud after losing by a mere 336 votes after mail-in ballots were counted.
(Ironically, Johnson was leading in Tuesday's Republican primary for state treasurer by a relatively narrow margin — but, surely, that vote tally is perfectly accurate.)
To be sure, there is plenty of popular support for expediting and improving the election process in states such as California and Nevada. Policies such as voter ID have typically been popular among voters of all ideological leanings — and it's not because the overwhelming majority of ordinary voters believe there are swarms of imposters trying to cast ballots behind their backs. Instead, it's because voters expect a certain amount of efficiency and security in our democratic system that currently seems to be lacking.
However, the lack of such security protocols or timely results don't give the losers of elections carte blanche to allege fraud without presenting hard evidence. Regardless of electoral procedures, the real reason behind most political losses in America (regardless of one's partisan affiliation) is the same as it has always been: voter preferences.
And on that front, this year could be pretty difficult for the candidates who survived Tuesday by portraying themselves as nothing more than avatars for President Donald Trump's new Republican Party.
For starters, midterm elections are often a rebuke of whichever party is currently in the White House. With inflation once again outpacing wage growth and a never-ending war "military action" in the Middle East, that's a historical trend that likely won't be stymied in 2026. Republicans who cling too tightly to the unpopular president's coattails are likely to find their races more challenging than they need to be.
In other words, just because a Trump endorsement is gold during the primaries doesn't mean it will remain so in the general — even for Republicans in otherwise "safe" seats, such as Nevada's 2nd Congressional District.
Those who live in MAGA's echo chamber, however, are sure to find this dynamic quite puzzling. And as we saw in L.A. earlier this week, any Republican losses — no matter how predictable or foreseeable — will be met with the sort of conspiracy-minded incredulity that has proliferated throughout the party since 2020's presidential election.
Here in Nevada, the Trumpian outcome of a great many primary battles helped stave off such hand-wringing for the time being. However, if Trump's preferred candidates don't fare as well among the broader, swingier, electorate come November, expect the incessant cries of "fraud" to become the official swan song of Republicans who are unwilling to craft concession speeches.
Indeed, such cries are almost as certain as L.A. electing a Democrat for mayor.
Michael Schaus is a communications and branding expert based in Las Vegas and founder of Schaus Creative LLC, an agency dedicated to helping organizations, businesses and activists tell their story and motivate change. He has more than a decade of experience in public affairs commentary, having worked as a news director, columnist, political humorist and most recently as the director of communications for a public policy think tank. Follow him on Twitter @schausmichael or on Substack @creativediscourse.
Support Independent Elections Coverage and Journalism in Nevada
You’ve enjoyed unlimited access to our reporting because we’re committed to providing independent, accessible journalism for all Nevadans.
But sustaining this work — informing communities, holding leaders accountable, and strengthening civic life — depends on readers like you.
Nevada needs strong, independent journalism. Will you join us?
A gift of any amount helps keep our reporting free and accessible to everyone across our state and funds our elections coverage.
Choose an amount or learn more about membership

